Timely and specific performance feedback, coupled with a coaching relationship will build the confidence, skill, and experience of your team members. The University uses two formal feedback points with benefit-eligible staff members: the 90-day Probationary Review and the Annual Review.
90 Day Probationary Review for New Employees
New employees should receive regular feedback throughout the 90-day probationary period. The probationary period should include a 90-day review with the employee. Managers will be asked to provide Human Resources with feedback on the new employee via an automated process generated by my.SMU.
Click on the 90 Day tab above to learn more about the process.
Annual Performance Review
Employees should be given feedback throughout the year culminating in an annual performance review, which summarizes the year. The Annual Review process takes place in the spring semester, from mid-January to mid-April.
Click on the Annual Performance Review tab above to learn more about the process, access the review forms, and understand who should receive an annual review.
90 Day Probationary Review for New Employees
Online Review Process
All employees benefit from regular and timely feedback. New employees are in need of clear expectations and regular feedback throughout their first 90 days on the job. Managers should be scheduling frequent one-on-one meetings and taking opportunities to provide feedback on a more informal basis during this time.
90 Day Review Process
The new employee's manager will be prompted via automated emails to submit the review within Access.SMU. Automated emails to the manager will begin on day 60 of the new employee's probationary period and continue on a regular basis until the online review form is completed or until the employee reaches his or her 86th day of employment, which is the last day a performance review will be accepted in Access.SMU. Please note these emails will come from Access.SMU@smu.edu - check your junk mail account if you think you are not receiving these emails.
Human Resources Support
The manager will receive an automated confirmation email after completing the online review form . A member of the Employee Relations team will review the document and contact the manager to help address any identified performance issues. If performance issues arise early in the probationary period, managers are encouraged to contact Human Resources quickly for support.
Probationary Review Due Date
The probationary review is due by the employee's 86th day of employment. This enables Human Resources to provide any needed assistance prior to the conclusion of the probationary period. Unless action is taken, such as an extension to probation, an employee who passes the 90th day on the job is considered a regular employee. Subsequent performance issues are typically handled through coaching and the progressive discipline process.
Additional information may be accessed using the links below including: instructions on accessing and completing the online form, review questions regarding employees who are not meeting expectations and the types of options managers may request, holding a review discussion and retaining probationary period documents.
SMU Strategic Plan for 2016-2025
Managerial Options During Probation:
Annual performance reviews are to be conducted for all regular (benefits-eligible) staff members in the spring semester, between January and April. Completed original forms are due to the Department of Human Resources by close of business on Friday, April 22, 2016.
Please Note: If a new employee began work prior to January 1 of the current review period (Jan-April), an Annual Review will need to completed for this employee during the the review period. The online 90 Day Performance Review will not substitute for an annual review. If the employee was hired after January 1, an Annual Review will not be required for him/her until the following year.
Reviews should be completed and forwarded to HR/Employee Relations, PO Box 750232, Department of Human Resources by the due date. A number of divisions and schools require reviews be submitted internally before they are sent to Human Resources. Please inquire with your internal administration about earlier deadlines.
Performance Review and Goal Setting Forms
HR rolled out new performance review forms for the 2016 annual review period (Jan-April 2016).
The process includes two new forms: one focused on the Year in Review and the second on The Year Ahead. The Year in Review form should be submitted to HR for the Annual Performance Review documentation by the published due date. The Year Ahead conversation should be initiated at the same time as the Year in Review conversation and should focus on the development of goals for the upcoming year.
Year in Review: Regular coaching and feedback should have occurred through the year, therefore the year in review form provides the opportunity to summarize the highlights of the past year's goals and accomplishments. Managers and employees should individually complete the form before meeting for the review session. After the review session, the manager should summarize the conversations and finalize the Year in Review form. The year in review form is the required form to be forwarded to HR by the published due date and a copy should be provided to the employee.
The Year Ahead: The main focus of this conversation between the manager and employee is on developing goals for the upcoming year. Several goals should be identified and should align the employee's efforts with departmental and team initiatives which are known at the time. The employee and the manager should complete the form individually before meeting and then come to agreement on future goals during the session. A final copy should be generated and the manager and employee should have the final copy for future reference. Goals may be adjusted throughout the year based on new initiatives, changing priorities, or shifts in employee/team responsibilities. The Year Ahead form for FY 16-17 is designed to be a living document where coaching conversations and regular check-ins can be documented, culminating in a Year in Review conversation for the next Review Period starting in January 2017.
HR will be offering several sessions on the new forms on the following dates and times. Managers are encouraged to attend a session to learn more about the process and the strategies for effective performance conversations.
|| Feb. 11
|| 9-10:30 am
|| HTSC, Portico Rooms BCD
|| Feb 23
|| 2-3:30 pm
|| Huitt-Zollar Pav, Embrey Bldg 115
|| Mar 7
|| 2-3:30 pm
|| HTSC, Forum
Enroll in a scheduled session via my.SMU. Search by course title of "Performance Review Workshop".
If you are interested in hosting a session for your internal group, email DevelopU@smu.edu.
Performance Review Forms
Resources for Goal Setting Conversations
SMU has identified the following core competencies and behaviors which lead to success at the University. These are included in the Performance Management process via my.SMU.
In addition to the core, other competencies and behaviors may apply to certain job responsibilities or projects. Access a list of the most common as a reference. These may be added in the Performance Management process in my.SMU.
|| This competency reflects the ability to be honest and committed and to value other’s positions equally as own:
- Communicates an understanding of the other person's interests, needs and concerns.
- Remains open to others' ideas and opinions even when they conflict with their own.
- Identifies and communicates shared interests and goals.
- Identifies and communicates differences as appropriate.
- Makes and meets commitments that contribute to addressing the other person's interests, needs, and concerns.
- Addresses perceived harm to the other person by fully acknowledging any harm done, clarifying intentions, and finding a suitable remedy that affirms the value of the relationship.
- Uses an approach to resolving conflicts or conducting negotiations which lead to positive outcomes success for all involved.
- Shares thoughts, feelings, and rationale so that others understand personal positions.
- Develops, maintains, and strengthens partnerships with others inside or outside the organization who can provide information, assistance, and support.
|| This competency reflects the ability to give and gather information and to actively manage the communication process:
- Listens to and considers other’s views
- States own views clearly and concisely
- Asks questions to find out other’s real views and check understanding
- Tackles disagreement constructively
- Conveys complex information in plain language
- Has a manner, style and presence in written and oral communication that makes a positive impression
- Ensures that information is passed on to others who should be kept
|| This competency reflects the ability to manage interpersonal relationships, both between self/other and other/other:
- Recognizes differences of opinion, brings them out into the open for discussion, and looks for win-win solutions
- Establishes a clear and compelling rationale for resolving the conflict
- Uses appropriate interpersonal styles and methods to reduce tension or conflict between two or more people
- Finds agreement on issues and follows through on implementation
- Deals effectively with others in an antagonistic situation
- Manages relationships and builds trust in the process
|| This competency reflects the ability to focus on own development and to take action to learn:
- Understands self-development if important to organizational success
- Is able to accurately identify own development needs
- Takes responsibility for setting up their own learning opportunities
- Reflects and consciously learns from experience
- Evaluates own performance
- Actively seeks feedback to assist with continuous self-improvement
- Open to learning
|| This competency reflects the ability to:
- Responds appropriately on own to improve outcomes, processes or measurements, including anticipating student/customer reactions and gathering information or planning accordingly
- Assumes responsibility and leadership when asked
- Accomplishes goals independently, with little need for supervision
- Takes ownership and accountability for own performance
- Seeks out and/or accepts additional responsibilities in the context of the job.
||Problem Solving - Decision Making
|| This competency reflects the ability to evaluate or judge the best course of action and to make decisions at the appropriate speed:
- Can make considered decisions quickly when necessary
- Develops solutions that are considerate for all involved
- Applies common sense when making decisions
- Seeks expert advice or objective opinions before making decisions
- Is prepared to be influenced by sound arguments and new information or evidence
- Is prepared to make tough decisions and is prepared to see them through
||This competency reflects the ability to get on well with a wide range of people and build long term trusting relationships:
- Is good at resolving people issues before they get out of hand
- Builds rapport with people
- Notices when others need help and support
- Goes out of way to develop trust in relationships
- Is sensitive to the unspoken feelings of others
- Brings tensions to the surface, helps to resolve conflicts and produces a positive outcome
- Looks for common ground and builds co-operation even in difficult circumstances
|| Resource Management
||This competency reflects the ability to identify, prioritize, and manage resources (physical, financial and human) to foster productivity and achieve organizational goals:
- Identifies resources available to the organization
- Effectively and efficiently manages the use of existing resources
- Ensures the appropriate amount of resources are available at the appropriate time in order to accomplish the business goals (not too much and not too few)
- Assigns the appropriate people to tasks that will keep them busy without overworking them or providing too much downtime
- Cooperatively work with others to share resources
- Follows all policies and procedures for tracking, submitting, and accounting for resource utilization
||This competency reflects the pursuit of the highest level of customer service:
- Shows respect and friendliness to customers
- Develops and maintains effective student/customer relationships
- Anticipates future customer needs and trends
- Focuses on identifying opportunities to benefit customers
- Talks and listens to customers to clarify their real needs and expectations
- Strives to resolve customer concerns
- Offers advice and guidance in responding to customer inquiries
||This competency reflects the ability to contribute to teams and to improve their effectiveness through personal commitment:
- Supports less experienced colleagues
- Encourages a strong sense of team spirit
- Focuses the team on what will contribute to success in the long term
- Develops ideas and solutions jointly with others
- Gives fair and constructive feedback to team members
- Takes responsibility for team's actions
- Develops a wide network of productive relationships around the business