Awarding of Rank and Tenure

Policy number: 2.11

Policy section: Academic Affairs

Revised Date: November 16, 2026


1.  Policy Statement

It is the policy of the University to award tenure to faculty who have achieved significant distinction and achievement in the areas of research/creative activity and teaching, while recognizing that it is an immensely important decision – both for the faculty member in question and for the long-term academic quality of the University.

2.  Purpose

The purpose of this policy is to define and outline the promotion and tenure process for tenure-track and tenured faculty. University Policy 2.11 is the only determinant policy for promotion and tenure decisions. Each College, School, and unit may offer supporting information and clarification of internal processes that can be updated annually. Such information, including annual updates, reflect guidance to help candidates understand the process, but explicitly do not reflect policy and are not meant to be representations of the University’s tenure standards. University policy is in effect for all faculty in any given year of the promotion and tenure cycle. The principal factors to be considered in evaluations for promotion and tenure are (a) distinction in research or equivalent creative activity (hereafter research/creative activity) and (b) effective teaching. Valued service to the University and to the profession to which the faculty member belongs will be taken into consideration for both promotion in rank and award of tenure but cannot substitute for the primary factors of research/creative activity and teaching.

3.  Rank and Tenure

  1. The appointment to the rank of assistant professor requires the potential for meeting the standards in this policy for promotion and tenure.
  2. Tenure is not attained automatically but only through the deliberative process described in this policy that takes place across multiple levels of review, culminating in the final approval by the Board of Trustees. Each step of the review contributes input that adds incremental value throughout the overall process. Tenure is awarded to those faculty who are outstanding in research/creative activity and whose performance in teaching is outstanding or of high quality. Each department or school may provide discipline-specific guidance for candidates to consider as they assemble their dossiers. Tenure cannot be granted on the basis of academic potential alone or by meeting a minimum threshold as described within college-, school- or unit-level documents that provide guidance to candidates. Demonstrated accomplishments in research/creative activity and teaching, including a robust forward trajectory, are essential. With the awarding of tenure, an assistant professor is promoted to associate professor.
  3. In some circumstances due to extended service at another university (usually without tenure) or at other institutions, an initial appointment may be at the rank of associate professor without tenure. The candidate for this appointment should have outstanding achievement in research/creative activity and the potential for meeting the standards for tenure at SMU within a time frame that should be specified in the initial appointment letter and that may not exceed six years.
  4. The rank of professor is the highest rank to which a faculty member may aspire. It should not be assumed that promotion to this rank will automatically follow from any certain number of years of service, nor should it be assumed that all faculty will achieve this rank. It should be reserved for those persons whose research/creative activity is recognized by members of the professional field as outstanding and sustained, with continued trajectory and promise, and whose teaching is judged by students and peers as either outstanding or of sustained high quality. It is generally expected that candidates for promotion to professor will have a more substantial service record than candidates for promotion to associate professor with tenure, who have primarily focused on their research/creative activity and teaching.
  5. For faculty who were at the assistant or associate rank prior to 2022, the requirements for consideration for tenure and promotion as stipulated in the University policy in effect at the time of the faculty member's initial appointment will continue through the 2026-2027 academic year. The one-year Covid extension policy will remain in effect during that period for assistant professors hired prior to 2022. This paragraph will be removed in May 2027 when it is no longer possible to be considered for tenure and promotion under that version of the University policy.

4.  Third-Year Review

As specified in the offer letter at the time of employment, an assistant professor’s initial appointment is subject to and contingent upon satisfactory annual performance reviews and the successful completion of a third-year review. The third-year review is conducted during the spring semester of the candidate’s third year and is a rigorous, mid-probationary review of the candidate's progress toward tenure. Such a review is conducted within the college or school according to its own internal procedures, with the Dean making a recommendation to the Provost, who makes the final decision whether the third-year review is successful. Candidates who are determined to not be demonstrating satisfactory progress toward tenure at the third-year review will have the remainder of their initial contract replaced with a transitional one-year, non-tenure track appointment (terminal year). The fourth year of employment will constitute the final contract year and will not be subject to further renewal or appeal. Candidates may choose to leave the employment of SMU and forego the terminal contract year and in doing so, forfeit any salary associated with the terminal year.

5.  Promotion and Tenure Process

  1. Normally, the tenure review process takes place either in the candidate’s sixth year or at a time specified in the initial appointment letter.
  2. There is no set period of time after promotion to the rank of associate professor to be considered for promotion to the rank of professor. Associate professors with tenure may request to be considered for promotion to full professor to the department chair, or to the dean in areas with no departmental structure. The department chair, after consulting with the full professors in the department, may choose to deny the request if it is clear that the faculty member does not meet the standards for promotion. If the request is denied, the department chair must provide feedback to the faculty member on the steps that are necessary for the case to go forward at a future date. In addition, the associate professor may appeal the decision to the Dean who will make the final decision on whether to initiate the promotion process. In schools that do not have departments or the equivalent, the associate professor may request of the Dean to be considered for the promotion process and may appeal a negative initiation decision by the Dean to the Provost, who will make the final decision. If a promotion to full professor case goes through the full consideration process but is ultimately unsuccessful, the faculty member may be considered for promotion in future years, but never in two consecutive years.
  3. Information and supporting documents pertinent to the action are assembled by the faculty member and others as appropriate and as prescribed by the schools, college, and University. These documents should include the evaluation of the candidate’s research or creative activity by at least six external reviewers, with at least three reviewers suggested by the department or school. The final list of reviewers must be approved by the Dean and Provost, who will take into account the quality of the reviewers and their institutions. The list of reviewers should not include individuals whose association with the candidate reflects a close personal or professional connection (e.g., mentors, former professors, direct collaborators, or co-authors). Evaluation of teaching should include evaluations by students and faculty colleagues.
  4. In accordance with the procedure of the schools and University, the documents are reviewed by the department (if applicable), the Dean’s Advisory Committee, and the Dean. At each level of the evaluation process, there should be thorough documentation evaluating the candidate’s research/creative activity, teaching, and accomplishments in serving the University and the profession. Candidates may choose to add additional materials between steps of the review process, for example, if new information becomes available. However, in no cases will such added materials be sent back for reconsideration of the case at a previous level of review.
  5. All promotion and tenure cases must be reviewed by the Dean, even if the department or department chair is not in favor of promoting and/or granting tenure to the candidate. The Dean submits recommendations to the Provost, either positive or negative, by a date established each year within the first two weeks of January.
  6. The Provost reviews the recommendations of the Deans, both positive and negative, as well as the supporting documents with the Provost’s Advisory Committee, a faculty committee appointed by the Provost. The Provost may choose to include the President in discussions. The Provost makes recommendations, either positive or negative, to the President.
  7. The President makes decisions to recommend granting promotion and/or tenure to the Board of Trustees or to deny promotion and/or tenure.

6.  Appeals

  1. Candidates will be informed of a negative recommendation by the Provost to the President. Such a recommendation may be appealed, within three weeks, to the President. Cases that are not appealed in this three-week time period proceed to the President with no further review or appeal available to the candidate. Candidates may submit additional information within the three-week window as part of an appeal.
  2. A negative decision by the President shall be final and cannot be appealed to the Board of Trustees.

The administrators named above may use, at their discretion, their advisory committees, ad hoc committees, or other counsel to provide advice on the matter of the appeal. Candidates who do not receive tenure or who choose not to go through the tenure review process are entitled to one additional year of employment on a non-tenure track appointment (terminal year). Candidates may choose to leave the employ of SMU and forego the terminal year contract as well as any salary associated with the terminal year.

7.  Early Consideration for Tenure

Early reviews are encouraged only in cases in which candidates are making unusually rapid progress, far exceeding the criteria for tenure as outlined above. Such a case should be clear and compelling. The written request to be considered early must be made by the candidate and approved in writing by both the Dean and Provost. The candidate will go through the normal tenure review process. Denial of early tenure will preclude the candidate from being considered again, as any early decision will be final.

In a previous version of this policy, candidates who joined SMU prior to 2022 could be considered more than once for tenure if they had gone through early consideration as described above. For all faculty hired prior to 2022, the former policy applies. This paragraph will be removed in May 2027, when it will no longer possible to be considered more than once for promotion to associate professor with tenure.

8.  Extension of the Probationary Period

Faculty members may request extensions of their probationary period in cases in which circumstances have arisen to interfere substantially with the research or creative activity of the faculty member. Such circumstances may include personal or family emergencies (e.g., life-threatening illness of the faculty member or a member of his/her immediate family) or problems beyond the faculty member’s control relating to his/her research or creative activity (e.g., delay of one semester or more in access to committed laboratory space in which to conduct research). Extensions due to childbirth and/or parental leave are discussed separately in University Policy 2.14, Additional Faculty Family and Medical Leave Benefits.

Requests to extend the probationary period for reasons other than childbirth and/or parental leave will be granted if they are deemed to be fair both to the faculty member making the request and to the University, and consistent with personnel practices generally applicable to other candidates for tenure in the University. These requests must be made by the faculty member in writing and must be submitted before the tenure review process has begun. The request must state clearly the circumstances in the faculty member’s situation that might justify an extended probationary period. The request is to be forwarded, in most cases via the department chair, to the Dean. If the Dean supports the request, the request, along with the Dean’s formal endorsement, is then sent to the Provost for further review and a final decision. If the Dean does not support the request, the faculty member will be notified and will be free to seek further review of the request by the Provost. In all cases, any decision to extend the probationary period will be made by the Provost. The faculty member will receive written notification when the request is approved or denied.

The total extension of the probationary period may not exceed two years, regardless of the combination of circumstances that resulted in the extension(s). Extensions counting toward the two-year limit include those that result from childbirth or parental leave. (Note—the Covid extension applies only to faculty hired on a pre-tenure line prior to fall 2022 and does not count toward the ceiling of two years. This clause will be removed when there are no more faculty members eligible for an extension for a Covid year under this provision.) No additional productivity is expected when a faculty member has obtained approval for an extension of the probationary period.

9.  Expedited Tenure Review for External Hires

When a candidate is being considered for hire at a rank with tenure, an expedited tenure review is required. The process for these reviews is similar to a normal tenure review. For cases in which the prospective faculty member’s proposed rank is the same as the faculty member’s current rank (i.e., a lateral move in terms of rank) and the stature of the institution where the prospective faculty member achieved the current rank is at the level of SMU or higher, only three reference letters need be used as the external letters in the review process. Suggestions for the external reviewers can be put forward by the prospective faculty member.

In cases in which the prospective faculty member’s proposed rank is higher (i.e., a vertical step in terms of rank) than the faculty member’s current rank – or, when the stature of the institution where the prospective faculty member achieved the current rank is not at the level of SMU or higher – evaluations from at least six external reviewers are required. Consistent with the SMU policy on tenure and promotion, at least three independent external reviewers must be selected by the department, and three can be requested from reviewers recommended by the candidate.

Expedited reviews may occur at any time of year, and the members of the Dean’s or Provost’s advisory committees may provide their evaluations to the Dean or Provost, respectively, solely through written communications. Meetings to discuss the case may be called at the discretion of the Dean or Provost.

10.  Expedited Promotion Review for Internal Faculty

In exceptional cases, current SMU faculty are also eligible to make a request to be considered for expedited review. Eligibility for requesting an expedited review must include a written offer letter that includes a promise for a vertical promotion step upon hire (to either associate or full professor) from an institution with stature at the rank of, or higher, than SMU. In such circumstances, the Provost will make a determination about eligibility for expedited review after consultation with the Dean. Candidates for expedited review will go through the same level of rigorous review as in the regular process for consideration of promotion to associate or full professor. This includes a minimum of six external review letters, with at least half of the reviewers to be selected by faculty in the home tenure department or school. All cases must go through each level of the process including department, college/school, and Provost review, as appropriate. A negative tenure decision made during the expedited tenure process for promotion to associate professor with tenure will preclude the candidate from being considered again, as the decision will be final. Faculty who receive a negative decision for promotion to full professor through this expedited process cannot apply in the year immediately following the decision. The appeals process for internal expedited review will follow the same procedures as described in section 2.11.6, with the final decision made by the President.

11.  Questions

Questions regarding this policy should be directed to the Office of the Provost.


Revised: November 16, 2026

Adopted: December 7, 2001

The official University Policy Manual is housed in the Office of the University Secretary. The University Secretary is responsible for maintaining new and updated policies and for maintaining this website. Should the official University Policy Manual conflict with any internal policies, procedures, departmental administrative rules, or guidelines, that may be contained in manuals provided by schools, departments, or divisions within the University, the official University Policy Manual controls.