This story first appeared on The Chronicle for Higher Education

2 Professors Are Brains Behind CNN's Live Audience Tracking at Conventions 

By Michael Stratford; September 4, 2012

Charlotte, N.C. — During his acceptance speech last week at the Republican National Convention, Mitt Romney affirmed his anti-abortion stance and his opposition to gay marriage, an appeal to his party’s conservative base that, predictably, drew thunderous applause from the audience.

But among a group of about two dozen undecided Florida voters assembled in a television studio just outside the Tampa Bay Times Forum, where Mr. Romney was speaking, his one-liner about social issues tanked. The undecided voters’ average rating for the speech fell into the thirties, hitting one of the lowest points of the night on the zero-to-100 scale.

“All the pundits were talking about abortion last week, but these social issues are not important to real undecided voters,” said Rita Kirk, a communications professor at Southern Methodist University who conducts live dial-testing of political events for CNN.

Since the 2008 election cycle, Ms. Kirk and her research partner, Daniel Schill, an assistant professor of communications at Southern Methodist, have been gathering groups of undecided voters and recording, in real time, their reactions to presidential debates and election-night speeches, among other events. After running groups at last week’s Republican National Convention, they will be doing the same here at this week’s Democratic National Convention.

The pair first pitched the focus-group idea to CNN in 2007 as an innovative way to report on presidential campaigns.

“We wanted to get the issues real voters care about back into the conversation,” Ms. Kirk said, adding that the focus groups not only make for “good television” but offer a more meaningful level of analysis to the coverage.

Before setting up shop at the Republican convention last week, the professors called 5,000 randomly selected Florida voters, from which they settled on a group of 57 who were undecided. About half of them participated each night of the convention.

On Thursday night, as the speeches began, the voters turned the knobs on wireless, handheld dials to indicate their level of satisfaction with what they were hearing.

Several feet away in the CNN studio, Ms. Kirk, Mr. Schill, and their team of undergraduate assistants hovered around monitors that displayed the voters’ average approval, broken down by gender. They Tweeted notable trends and passed along their analysis to a reporter, Tom Foreman. Mr. Foreman then asked the voters follow-up questions for an on-air segment.

During the highly produced biographical video introducing Mitt Romney at the convention, Mr. Schill noted that the female voters were responding more favorably than the men by a 20-point margin. The overall response rate, though, was tepid compared with previous such promotional videos, he added.
A handful of themes are sure bets for a strongly positive reaction from the undecided voters, Mr. Schill said. Not surprisingly, feel-good remarks about the American dream, opportunity, and hard work are the ones that consistently perform well. Negative statements about an opponent, by contrast, tend to evoke instantaneous disapproval from those in the focus groups, he said.

A lack of change in voters’ reactions can also provide insight into how they are receiving a speech, according to Mr. Schill, who teaches a class on political rhetoric.

“He’s flat-lining,” Mr. Schill said at one point on Thursday night, directing attention to a perfectly horizontal line appearing on the chart for several seconds during a speech by Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida. “That means he’s lost their attention. From a speechwriter’s perspective, you want to have more of a crescendo there.”
Both professors, who published an article on their findings from the 2008 election in American Behavioral Scientist, acknowledged that their dial-testing was limited in scope but served an important purpose nonetheless.

“We’re not pollsters. We’re not trying to find out where a large number of people stand on issues,” Ms. Kirk said. “Our goal is to see which arguments are resonating and ask, Why are those arguments resonating?”

Read more: The Chronicle for Higher Education, Chronicle Election Blog, September 4, 2012 

News Room

News Archive 2014

News Archive 2013

News Archive 2012

2 Professors Are Brains Behind CNN

Seven Things Happening Today

80 Years Later

9/11 Reshaped Lives of Muslims

Allan Sloan on Marketplace

American Cynicism on Rise

American Dream Shattered

Annual Conference of the Professions

Art Blog of Sandie

BART Controversy Centers on Social Media

BART Social Media Crackdown Uncharted Legal Territory

Bauer incentive Scholarship

Campaign Hits Ground

Campaign 2012: SMU Experts Weigh In

Commemorating Nine Eleven

Council Fields Trip to SMU

Dallas Council to Attend Ethics Class

Dallas Council to Attend Ethics Conference

Dallas Fort Worth 9/11 Events

Dallas Mayor Discusses Education

Dallas Philanthropist Dies

Dallas City Officials Say Party Funds Sought Inappropriately

Dennis Simon speaks on civil rights movements 50th anniversary

DFW International Community Alliance

Distinguished Professor Dennis Simon Pressents "Politics of Memory and Legacy of Civil Rights" on Oct. 1

Eagle Scholars First in Families

Earning Trust Demand for Ethics Leadership

'E-Democracy' the new 'grassroots'

Engaged Learning

Ethical Leadership in Government

Ethics of Financial Transparency

Ethics Trust & Transparency Conference

Frito Lay Plano Library Possibility

Frito Lay Plano Library Possibility

Future of Education KERA

Giveing perspective to the GOP Convention in Tampa Bay

GOP debates get physical

Gov Perry Hits Pres Campiagn Trail

Humann Recieves Reward

Humann Recognized

Is it Okay for Women to Curse at Work

Letters to the President

KERA Future of Education

Kimberly Clark Wins Ethics Award

Komen Reverses Cut to Planned Parenthood

KRLD Interviews Two SMU Professors About Their Dial Testing Technology

Leadership in Government Ethics

Legacies of September 11th

Legacies of September 11th D-Mag

Dial Testing in South Carolina

Looking back and ahead

Maguire Center Helps Students

Marin of Error: Two Candidates, Two Journeys, One lost race of dreams

Medallion Awards: Rita Kirk

Muslims Fight for Acceptance

Mustangs Jump into DNC Politics

September 11 Memorial Events at SMU

Oil Comapny and Houston settle 20 years of wrangling

In online journal, SMU students share memories of 9/11

9/11 Blog- Dallas Morning News

Panel Discusses Civil Liberites

Pegasus News: 9/11 Week

PolicyPulse Tests

Practical Advice from Commuication Experts

Prosecution of Top Government Offiicals for Torture

In Public and Private Forth Worth Residents Remember 9/11

Rais Bhuiyan of Dallas speaks message of forgiveness

Report on SMU Ethics Program

Report back: Yoo v. Pitts debate in Dallas

Responsible Business Leadership

Ryan's speech gives undecided voters mild nudge towards Romney

Share your 9/11 Story

SMU conference examines natinoal security and civil liberites

SMU Experts, organizations teach an electoral college 2012

SMU experts discuss Rick Perry's 2012 presidential run

SMU Experts: Rick Perry's quest for the presidency

SMU Eyes Bright Future

SMU's Home Opener on 9/11 to Feature Patriotic Theme, Special Military Tribute

SMU to honor tenth anniversary of 9/11

SMU honors 9/11 with thought provoking events

SMU honors distinguished alumni and emerging leader

SMU honors 9/11 with thought provoking events- SMU Website

SMU Hosts Luncheon Honoring Millitary Veterans

To Mark September 11 Anniversary, SMU Launches Website

SMU 9/11 Journal Helps Students Cope a Decade Later

SMU, Park Cities, Remember, Honor 9/11

SMU Student Honors 9/11 Victim Father

SMU Student Remembers Dad Who Died in 9/11

Brave New World: SMU to examine social media ethics in law, medicine, and religion

Christina Rancke

Strong Ethics Must Start at the Top

Student honors, volunteers in memory of her father

Tables of Content Tables Host- Rita Kirk

The Big Short Discussion Continues

Theology of Terorism Discussed

The Trust Barometer

To commemorate the 10th annivarsary of 9/11, SMU hosted a range of public events

Sepember 11th Anniversary Website- Dallas Observer

Across the Nation, Tragedy Spawned Inspiration

Turner reflects on September 11, 2001

University Ceremony Remembers Victims

Using Social Media to Tell Sandy's Story

SMU Voter Rally to be Part of SMU's Constitution Day 2012

On 9/11 Vows of Rememberance

Walt Humann to Recieve SMU Award

Website Raises Awarness

Wat connects with political convention viewers

Robin Lovin: what went wrong? 9/11

What Went Wong? PBS

News Archive 2011

Ethics Blog
© Southern Methodist University, Dallas, Texas | Legal Disclosures | A-Z Site Index | Contact SMU