|
Resumes, networking, referrals, and phone calls get
you the interview, but the interview gets you the job.
Preparation and practice are critical to interviewing
success.
PREPARATION
to top
The following are guidelines for preparation.
Please remember that there is no "right" set
of rules of interviewing. It is an interpersonal
communication situation. You must develop a style that
is comfortable for you. These guidelines should help
you do just that.
Review and reflect on the information in your
resume. This is essential for effective preparation.
You must be able to answer any questions that your
resume might raise.
Be able to give concise, yet complete and accurate
responses. The interview is a discussion process. Be
prepared to discuss, not just "answer."
Know Yourself
Know your abilities and the skill areas you have
developed through course work and experiences (paid or
volunteer). Self-assessment that examines your skills
and abilities, interests, values, career goals,
strengths and weaknesses is essential. If done
properly, your assessment will prepare you to discuss
the aspects of your background that qualify you for a
specific position. Speak with a counselor to determine
the best career assessment(s) to take to clarify your
interests and skills and how those may match certain
positions.
Know your strengths and weaknesses. Rather than
attempting to bluff or fake information concerning a
weak subject, whenever possible, make a transition
from a "weakness" to a strength or discuss
how you are working on strengthening a particular
weakness.
Be able to articulate your career goals—both long
and short-term. It is most important to be able to
project a sense of "career direction." You
may not be able to outline the next ten years of your
life or predict where you will be in five years, but
you should be prepared to state what you want to do
professionally and show that you know of some possible
career paths that you can take. This requires doing
your homework—self-assessment and career research—prior
to the interview. If you have difficulty in
articulating career goals, the Career Center suggests
that you utilize one of our assessment options.
Graduate school may be part of your life’s plan, but
unless you have applied, been accepted and intend to
go in the near future, it is not something that needs
to be shared in a job interview.
Employers often ask questions regarding past
performance and experience, so be familiar with your
work experiences. Be prepared to describe your duties,
responsibilities, and accomplishments, e.g., managing
a $25,000 budget as a treasurer of an organization or
planning a seminar that brought well-known speakers to
campus. Discuss how your work has initiated results;
e.g., chairing a fund-raising event that netted $5,000
or presenting a seminar that was attended by more than
300 students.
Mention the coursework and class projects you have
had that are applicable to the job for which you are
interviewing. You may wish to bring a copy of your
transcripts or a listing of relevant courses to the
interview if courses are not discussed in your resume.
Know the Organization
The brief time you spend with the employer’s
representative in the interview is your opportunity to
stand out among other candidates who possess similar
credentials. By being thoroughly prepared you will
know what to expect...what kind of questions will be
asked...how to respond...and how to act. Being
prepared for the interview can make all the difference
in the image you project and in your ability to use
the interview to your best advantage.
Become familiar with the company/employer with who
you are sseeking employment - their products,
structure, services, financial status, competitors,
reputation, and any recent major changes. By learning
as much as possible about your employer, you will be
able to ask more meaningful questions. The interviewer
will be impressed with your diligence, and may well
relate how you prepare for the interview with how you
might prepare for future business meetings. Although
an employer may seek a unique skill, many of the same
qualities are sought by employers whether they are in
business, government or education.
Look to the following sources for employer
information:
• Career Center Library • Annual reports (Fondren
& BIC)
• Job descriptions • Career counselors
• Internet sites • Current employees
Connect Your Skills with Employers’ Needs
Be prepared to show how your coursework, past
experience and/or skills would be valuable to the
organization or useful in the job for which you are
applying. Present your qualifications in terms of
having something of value to offer the organization.
Use specific details and examples—experience,
avocations, travel, extracurricular or community
activities, courses, projects, etc. Do not leave it up
to the interviewer to make the connection between the
facts on your resume and the degree to which you are
uniquely qualified for the position. Make reference to
your past as illustrated on your resume while
discussing your future and potential performance on
the job. Learn as much as possible about the actual
day-to-day functions of the job before or during the
interview. This knowledge will enable you to
effectively make the above-discussed
"connection."
The Interview
to top
Did you know that it only takes 20 seconds to
formulate an opinion? You never get a second chance to
make a positive first impression! Therefore, you
personal behavior and appearance are important
considerations in an interview. The manner in which
you carry yourself, dress, speak and act will all
contribute to the image you are building for the
interviewer.
Appearance
to top
Consider the following guidelines: Neatness and
cleanliness in dress and appearance. No severe or
outlandish dress. Dress for the position you aspire to
have. Dress so that dress isn't an issue.
Males
- A dark colored (black, navy, gray, or olive
green) two piece suit recommended.
- Wearing a nicely pressed dress shirt is
recommended along with a white T-shirt under the
dress shirt.
- Ties of medium width are considered classic and
should be tied to hang at the tip of your belt
buckle.
- Socks should match the shoes or slacks whichever
is darker.
- Do not forget to polish your shoes, it says a
lot about you and your attention to details.
Females
- Women traditionally have been advised to wear a
suit with a skirt that is neatly tailored.
Conservative colors such as navy, black, olive
green, plum, and camel are suggested.
- The length of the suit skirt should be either just
above the knee or at mid calf level; mini or
mid-thigh skirts are never appropriate for an
interview.
- Solid colored blouses and hosiery are recommended.
Hosiery should match your shoes or skirt which ever
is darker.
- The classic two-inch pump works best for
presenting a professional image. Shoes should be
polished with the heels and soles in good repair.
Grooming for Males and Females
- Hair should be trimmed or pulled away from face.
It is suggested that you do not get a trim or
experiment with a new look the day before our
interview.
- Jewelry should not be distracting. Avoid wearing
multiple rings and earrings that are dangling. Men
who wish to present a conservative image should not
wear earrings.
- Be sparing with fragrances. Some people are very
sensitive to colognes and perfumes; especially small
spaces such as interview rooms.
- Don't forget to give your hands a good washing and
your nails a trim. Women should avoid bright,
vibrant nail polish that could draw attention to
your hands and away from you.
- Visible tattoos and body piercings are frowned
upon in many industries. Cover them if possible.
Interview Checklist
to top
Arrival:
Arrive 10 to 15 minutes early. Much
can be learned from chatting with a receptionist, a
secretary or other employees while you are waiting.
Allow enough time to take care of last minute details
such as adjusting your ties, combing your hair, ect.
Never be late!
Bring: Extra resumes, list references,
transcript and portfolio (notepad and pen). You may
also want to bring documents/items that illustrate
your skills. Turn off all cell phones and pagers, or
better yet do not bring them to the interview at all.
You should be completely focused on the interview.
Names: Be sure you know how to pronounce the
interviewer's name correctly, and get the names of all
people you meet throughout the interview. Asking for
business cards is a good method of collecting employer
contact info including: names, phone numbers, and the
correct spelling of names for future correspondence.
Handshake: A firm handshake is a must when
beginning and ending your interview.
Manners: Be personable as well as professional,
and above all be polite to everyone you meet. Many
employers query the secretary or greeters on how the
candidate behaved and what the candidate said before
the interview. Any time you interact with a company's
employees you should treat it like an interview.
Body Language: Be aware of your body
language--use your instincts to keep things on course.
Maintain eye contact. Watch your posture and be aware
of mannerisms; avoid those that indicate tension or
nervousness, but do not inhibit natural gesturing. Do
not yawn or slouch.
Attitude: Your attitudes are vital. Be direct
and confident, but not arrogant. Be mentally alert and
emotionally in control (poised). Sincerity and honesty
are a must. If you are honest about your feelings and
about your qualifications, a "match" will be
made if there is to be one. If not, dishonesty may
result in a "mismatch," resulting in
unhappiness for both you and your employer.
Speech/Language: Speak clearly, audibly and
with enthusiasm. Be aware of your vocabulary and
grammar: avoid slang, trite phrases, or jargon that is
not specific to the industry for which you are
applying. Varied word choice is desirable. Avoid
over-use of common phrases. Be a good listener and an
active participant. Remember that an interview is a
communication/conversation process, not a
question-and-answer time. Do not mention personal,
domestic or financial problems. Be positive in your
approach.
Questions: Assume all questions are asked for a
good reason and answer accordingly. Feel free to ask
for clarification before answering a question. If
needed, take some time to formulate your answers
before you speak. Answer all questions honestly, but
in the best, most positive light. Be specific and give
examples of your past behavior to illustrate skills.
Review the "Types of Interviews" and
"Interview Questions" to prepare.
Former Employers: Do not, under any
circumstances, speak ill of former employers.
Interview Closure: Try to conclude the
interview with some understanding as to where you
stand, what is to happen next, who is to contact whom
and when the contact will be made. Interviewers do
judge candidates' interest in the job. Make it easy.
Say you want the job, if you do. Show a confident,
goal-directed attitude. Ask for a business card.
Remember to shake hands and thank the interviewer(s)
at the end of the interview.
Interview Follow Up
to top
A thank-you note to the interviewer
will always make a positive impression. The thanks-you
note can be simple, just stating your appreciation for
his/her time and consideration, or more complex,
stating appreciation, highlighting positive points
discussed during the interview, reinforcing
qualifications you possess, ect. Mail it within 24
hours of the interview. If the company has not
responded to you by the time they indicated, call to
emphasize you are still interested and inquire if a
decision has been made. The thank-you note could
distinguish you from other applicants. if an employer
is "sitting on the fence" regarding you and
another candidate, the thank-you note may make the
difference in the decision.
Interview Formats
to top
Interviews occur in a variety of
locations from the company site to on-campus to over
the telephone. Below are some of the more common
interview formats you are likely to encounter.
Familiarize yourself with the procedures from the
different interview formats so you are comfortable no
matter how or where the interview takes place.
On-Campus Interviews
Typically scheduled for either 30
or 45-minute intervals. On-campus interviews are
usually a "first-round interview," a
screening interview to determine if you have the
skills and experience needed to perform the duties of
the job. Check InterviewTrak for information on
specific companies.
Telephone Interviews
Telephone interviews are becoming more common. This
type of interview can offer unique challenges and
benefits, both of which you should be aware of BEFORE
you talk with your prospective employer.
One of the benefits of telephone interviewing is
that the interview is conducted "in your
space." You can be relaxed in your favorite
T-shirt and shorts, while you sit on your comfortable
couch (no annoying suits or awkward seating
arrangements). Another benefit of telephone
interviewing is that you can refer to notes.
One potential drawback of telephone interviews is
that although most interviewers will call ahead to
schedule a telephone interview, others may call you
out of the blue and expect to interview you on the
spot. As you begin to enter your job search,
anticipate these calls, and keep your resume,
interview notes and information on the companies to
which you’ve applied within reach of the telephone.
Perhaps the most challenging aspect of telephone
interviewing is the lack of visual cues. We depend a
great deal on facial expressions, body language, and
other non-verbals when talking with others. In a
telephone interview, most non-verbal cues are
unavailable. It can be difficult to distinguish
between interviewers, making it hard to address
individuals. If the interview occurs on a
speakerphone, it is almost impossible to receive
feedback — only one side can speak at a time.
Overall, it may be difficult to get a "feel"
for how the interview went.
DOs and DON’Ts in Telephone Interviews
Do notify roommate(s) that you may
receive calls from employers.
Do have a professional answering
machine message to receive calls from employers
Do treat phone interviews with all
the care and preparation you would a face-to-face
interview.
Do prepare (research,
self-awareness, have questions to ask the
interviewers, know who is interviewing you).
Do practice (practice answering
questions on the phone or speaker phone, set up a
telephone mock interview with a Career Center staff
person, or ask a friend to ask you "most asked
interview questions" over the phone).
Do arrange a time and place that is
convenient and conducive to a proper interview
environment. (Don’t schedule it when your roommate
likes to watch TV or at your job where interruptions
are probable).
Do be ready for an
"out-of-the-blue" telephone call.
Don’t read from your notes...you
don’t want to sound like you’re reading a script.
Don’t allow any interruptions
(deactivate or ignore call waiting, inform roommates
or friends of your scheduled interview).
Don’t let an
"out-of-the-blue" telephone call rattle you
- be ready.
Second Round Interviews
Each round of interviews takes
discussion of issues to a deeper level. Similar topics
may be covered from one round to the next, but in
greater detail. Individuals from various levels and
functions within the organization will participate in
the evaluation process. Don't be surprised to find
yourself answering the same questions over and over.
Second round interviews are most
often held at the employer's site, giving you the
opportunity to meet co-workers and to assess the work
setting. It is not unusual to be invited to talk with
6-12 people individually or in small groups. Your day
may stretch from breakfast through dinner, so be well
rested and prepared for a long day. Study the On-Site
Interviews section for more information on
preparing for the second round interview.
Some companies, usually consulting
firms and investment banks, make their decisions about
whom to offer second-round interviews quickly - within
one to seven days. At the opposite extreme, firms will
leave you hanging for 6 weeks or more before informing
you whether you will be taken to the second round. Or
they may never get back to you. Most employers let you
know where you stand within 2 weeks.
On -Site Interviews
On-site interviews may occur in
either the first or second round of interviewing.
First round interviews conducted at the on-site will
require more planning and initiative on your part than
an on-campus interview, but otherwise the same
procedures will apply. Always inquire about the
interview process when making the arrangements. What
type of interview should you expect, the timeframe,
how many people will be involved, will the interview
be with individuals or groups? Don’t forget to ask
for specific directions to the location, who will meet
you when you arrive, and where to meet. Always get the
name and phone number of the contact person for
further contact if necessary.
You will encounter various
processes for "on-site" interviews
(interviews held at the employer’s location.) The
on-site interview may require you to drive to Plano or
to fly to New York City. It may last all-day or just a
few hours. Work with the employer to schedule the
on-site visit at a mutually convenient time. Sometimes
employers will try to arrange site visits for several
candidates to take place at the same time, so there
may not be much flexibility but you'll never know if
the employer is flexible unless you ask.
Preparing for the On-Site Interview
- An invitation to an on-site interview, often
referred to as the "plant trip," is NOT
a guarantee of a job offer. It is a chance to
examine whether or not you will be a good match
for the job and for the organization.
- Notification of a plant trip may be by telephone
or mail. Respond promptly if you are sincerely
interested in this employer. Decline politely if
you are not. Never go on a plant trip for the sake
of the trip. Document the name and phone number of
the person coordinating your trip. Verify who will
be handling trip expenses. Most medium and
large-size companies (as well as many smaller
ones) will pay your expenses, but others will not.
This is very important, because expenses are
handled in various ways: 1) the employer may
handle all expenses and travel arrangements; 2)
you handle your expenses and arrangements (the
employer may assist with this), and the employer
will reimburse you later; 3) the employer may
offer an on-site interview, but will not pay for
your interview.
- Know yourself and the type of job you are
seeking with this employer. Don't say, "I am
willing to consider anything you have."
- Thoroughly research the potential employer. Read
annual reports, newspaper articles, trade
journals, etc. Many companies have their own
homepage, where you can read its mission
statement, find out about its long-term goals,
read recent press releases, and view corporate
photos. Don't limit your research only to
company-controlled information. The World Wide Web
can be a valuable investigative tool. You may
uncover key information that may
influence-positively or negatively your decision
to pursue employment with a given organization.
- Bring extra copies of your resume; copies of any
paperwork you may have forwarded to the employer;
your reference list; an updated college
transcript; a copy of your best paper as a writing
sample; a notebook; a black and/or blue pen for
filling out forms and applications; and names and
addresses of past employers.
- Bring extra money and a change of clothes. Also,
have the names and phone numbers of those who may
be meeting you in case your plans change
unexpectedly. Anything can happen and you need to
be ready for emergencies.
- Your role at the interview is to respond to
questions, to ask your own questions and to
observe. Be ready to meet people who are not part
of your formal agenda. Be courteous to everyone
regardless of his or her position; you never know
who might be watching you and your actions once
you arrive in town.
- Don't forget your table manners. Plant trips may
include several meals or attendance at a reception
the night before your "big day." When
ordering food at a restaurant, follow the lead of
the employer host. For example, don't order the
three-pound lobster if everyone else is having a
more moderately priced entree. If you have the
"dining jitters," some authorities
suggest ordering food that is easy to handle, such
as a boneless fish fillet or chicken breast.
- Many employers have a set salary range for
entry-level positions and others are more
negotiable. Though salary should not be brought up
until an offer is extended, it is wise to know
your worth in advance. Contact the SMU Career
Center to obtain more information on salaries.
According to Jay Wheeler, Manager of University
Relations and Staffing for Halliburton,
"Students have been working on perfecting
their product for a number of years and should
know what kind of product they've created and what
the company is willing to buy."
- Soon after the site visit, record your
impressions of your performance. Review the
business cards of those you met or write the
information in your notebook before leaving the
facility. You should have the names, titles,
addresses and phone numbers of everyone who was
involved in your interview so you can determine
which individuals you may want to contact with
additional questions or follow-up information. A
thank-you letter should be written to the person(s)
who will be making the hiring decision. Stay in
touch with the employer if you want to pursue a
career with them.
A site visit is a two-way street.
You are there to evaluate the employer and to
determine if your expectations are met for job
content, company culture and values, organizational
structure, and lifestyles (both at work and leisure).
Take note of how the employees interact, and also
assess the physical work environment.
Just as any good salesperson would
never leave a customer without attempting to close the
sale, you should never leave an interview without some
sort of closure. If you decide that the job is right
for you, don't be afraid to tell the employer that you
feel that there is a good fit and you are eager to
join their team. The employer is interested in hiring
people who want to be associated with them and they
will never know of your interest if you don't voice
your opinion. Keep in mind that although the employer
has the final power to offer a job, your demeanor
during the entire interviewing process-both on and off
campus-also gives you a great deal of power.
Adapted from an article by Roseanne
R. Bensley, Placement and Career Services, New Mexico
State University
TYPES OF INTERVIEWS
to top
Employers use a variety of types of
interviews to determine if you are a good match for
their company. Be aware that employers may ask
questions from any of the interview types within your
interview. Be prepared!
Standard Interviews
Employers expect you to relay
specific, factual information about yourself. They
take your answers at their face value regarding what
you have accomplished and why. Most employers will
start the interview with the traditional questions
about your education, work experience, career
interests, etc. In return, you ask about the firm, job
and industry. The ideal interview flows like a
conversation, with a dynamic exchange of information
and ideas so parties get to know one another. The
employer may stick with these traditional questions or
move on to the types of interviewing to learn more
about your skills, abilities and personal
characteristics.
Behavioral Interviews
Employers are increasingly relying
on a method of selecting employees called
Behavioral-Based Interviewing. It is based on the
assumption that past behavior can predict future
performance. Interviewers determine their selection
criteria (competencies for the job), and then conduct
the interview by probing for examples that demonstrate
those skills or characteristics. In particular, they
are seeking information regarding a candidate’s
knowledge, motivations and past behaviors.
Focusing on STAR’s
guides the interviewer in collecting behavioral
examples and in evaluating job-specific data. The
examples you use to answer behavioral interview
questions must contain:
• The Situation/Task
you faced.
• The Action you
took (what did you do?)
• The Result of
your actions.
Typical questions that interviewers
ask to help build complete STAR’s
are:
• Describe a situation when...?
• Why did you...?
• What were the circumstances
surrounding...?
• Exactly what did you do?
• What was your specific role in
the project?
• What were the steps you took?
• What was the result?
• What problems/successes
resulted from...?
So, what does this mean for you and
how can you prepare for today’s interviewer? The
skilled behavioral interviewer will get past
"canned" or rehearsed answers.
Your job is to think of specific
examples of situations (whether in school, at a
part-time/summer job or in an extra-curricular
activity), that help to illustrate your strengths, how
you overcome obstacles, work with people on a team,
etc.
Evaluate your past experiences and
think of how you would specifically describe the Situation/Task,
the Action you took and Result
of your action.
Behavioral-Based Interviewing is a
"common-sense" approach to interviewing that
allows employers to treat all candidates fairly
(everyone is asked the same questions), and that
eliminates most of the guesswork regarding who is the
best candidate for the job.
For more assistance with preparing
for interviews consult with a career counselor, have a
mock interview, attend an Interviewing Workshop, and
read books or view videotapes in the Career Center
Library.
Information adapted from
Development Dimensions Int’l, Inc.
Analytical Interviews
Employers, typically from the
Consulting and Investment Banking industries, use
analytical interview questions or brainteasers to
explore your ability to use logic. What really matters
when answering an analytical question is your thought
process in arriving at a solution, rather than knowing
the one correct solution. The employer may even ask
you to develop alternate solutions to the same
question. (See the manhole cover example below.) The
key to doing well is to make sure your thinking is
clear and logical and to state your assumptions, if
there are any. Remember, there is no one
correct answer; it is how you approach the question
that counts.
Tips for Answering Analytical
Questions
- Don’t get bogged down in exact numbers: It is
better to select round numbers that you can easily
multiply or divide. Remember that (1) the
interviewer doesn’t care what numbers you use, and
(2) more accurate numbers might be harder to
manipulate, causing you to get your math wrong,
which the interviewer will not like.
- Don’t be afraid to think out loud: Doing
the work in your head and then presenting your
answer to the interviewer isn’t very useful.
They will not know how you arrived at your answer
and will probably ask you to describe your thought
process. Again, the interviewer is interested in
your ability to use logical reasoning.
- Don’t be afraid to ask "stupid"
questions: If there is some fact that you
need to know to answer the question (such as the
circumference of the earth) and you don’t know
it, either make up a reasonable number or ask the
interviewer. Don’t worry, it won’t be held
against you.
Example Solutions to Analytical
Questions:
A. How many blue cars are there in
the U.S.?
This is a standard type of
question. Because the most important thing is the
process you use, rather than the actual numbers, let’s
first devise an approach and then stick in some
estimates afterwards, using reasonable assumptions
along the way. Do the problem in a 2-step process:
Figure out the number of cars in
the country, remembering that corporations as well as
individuals can own cars.
Take a wild guess as to the subset
of cars that are blue.
Now put in the numbers, referring
to the 2-step process outlined above:
1a. (250 million people in
the country)*(an average of 0.5 cars per
person)=125 million cars owned by people. The
justification for the 0.5 is that it is a balance
between people who own their own cars and families
in which the cars are shared.
1b. Add another 20 million
cars on top of the 125 million to capture the
number of cars owned by corporations (such as
limousine/taxi companies, company cars, etc.)
1c. Total=125
million+20million=145 million cars in the country.
Let’s round up to 150 million to make the math
easier.
2. Because the color blue
is fairly common, let’s assume that 30% of cars
are blue. So, 30%* (150 million cars)=45 million.
This means that about 50 million blue cars exist
in the U.S.
B. Why is a manhole cover round?
First of all, a round manhole cover
cannot fall through the hole, and therefore cannot
slip into the sewer system or hurt someone working
beneath it. In addition, the rounded shape makes the
cover easier to roll and less dangerous to workers
since it lacks sharp edges. Finally, a round cover
does not have to be placed in a specific position to
fit over the hole.
This is a very difficult question
that few people get completely right. Basically, the
interviewer is gauging your reaction to being stumped.
Do you calmly admit ignorance, do you throw out as
many ideas as you can think of, do you try to talk
your way out of the predicament, or do you lose your
composure?
SOURCE: The Insider’s Guide to
Management Consulting: Opportunities for
Undergraduates by Gautam Prakash
Case Study Interviews
Commonly used by consulting firms,
this type of interview is designed to determine your
ability to logically analyze a business problem and to
work through it methodically. The employer is
interested in both the skills you demonstrate in
solving the case along with the process that leads to
your conclusion. The interviewer is not looking for
the "one right answer", but rather observing
your approach to the case study problem: how you
identify, structure and think through the problem
along with the skills you exhibit in reaching a
conclusion. The key to doing will is to make sure you
can support your assumptions with facts and reasoning
as you lay out your analysis of the problem and guide
the interviewer through your approach.
Skills Assessed in the Case Study
Interview:
Leadership/Confidence
Analytical Ability
Presentation/Verbal Communication
Energy
Attention to Detail/Organization
Quantitative
Flexibility
Maturity
Intelligence/Depth of Insight
Process for Answering Case Studies:
In a case interview, the employer
will describe a business dilemma facing a particular
company. You are asked to analyze the situation,
identify key business issues, and discuss how you
would address the problems involved. The interviewer
begins by giving you some basic facts. You then ask
you an open-ended or specific question to uncover key
information and move toward resolution. The interview
proceeds in an open dialogue between you and the
interviewer, with the interviewer guiding the
discussion.
Listen closely to the case interview
Develop your hypotheses (Begin to identify issues
& defining factors to consider)
Test your hypothesis (Identify facts/data needed
to prove or disprove, pursue data/facts, probe on
key issues)
Refine your hypotheses (Use of numbers, defend
path chosen)
Develop options (Analyze path chosen)
Summarize options & make recommendations(Brief
summaries: pro's & cons, beset option supported
by data, implementation)
Advice from Interviewers:
Don’t get bogged down in exact figures; use
rounded numbers
Think aloud; the interviewer wants to know your
reasoning/problem solving strategies
Don’t be afraid to ask "stupid"
questions; better to ask for clarification/facts
before proceeding
Common Mistakes
Misunderstanding the question or answering the
wrong question. Listen closely and clarify exactly
what’s being asked.
Proceeding in a haphazard fashion (i.e., not
identifying the major issues that need to be
examined or jumping from one issue to another). Be
organized in your approach.
Asking a barrage of questions without
explaining to the interviewer why you need the
information. Let the employer know why you’re
asking the question so he/she can follow your
thought process.
Force-fitting a few familiar business frameworks
to every case question, whether they are relevant or
not, or misapplying a relevant business framework
that you do not really understand, rather than
simply using common sense.
Not being able to synthesize a point of view based
on the information provided by the interviewer.
Case Study Interview Resources:
Books: The Insider’s Guide to Management
Consulting & The Fast Track (Career Center
Library)
Practice Case Studies on Company Web Sites: Bain
& Company, Boston Consulting Group, Ernst &
Young, McKinsey & Company
SMU MBA Consulting Club Web Site: (information and
links to other useful sites) http://www.smu.edu/~mbaconsult/resource_2.html
Online Resources: Vault.com’s free electronic
newsletter available at www.vault.com and Wet Feet
Press at www.wetfeet.com/asp/home.asp
Stress Interview
You may experience a stress
interview where the interviewer intentionally
confronts or challenges you to create tension. You
might be told your decision to pursue a degree at SMU
was a waste of money, that your extracurricular
activities sound shallow, or that your background has
no relevance to the firm's work. The interviewer puts
you on the defensive or makes you angry to see how you
respond to uncomfortable or difficult interpersonal
situations. Stress interviews are most often used by
client-centered businesses, like consulting or
investment banking firms, whose frustrated or
aggressive clients will challenge you in similar ways.
Firms want to see if you remain cool in the face of
adversity and think well on your feet.
Team Activities
These team or group activities
typically take place during an on-site interview. You
and other applicants form a small group that has been
assigned a business or technical problem. The employer
gives you the information and tools you need to solve
the task. The employer either has you answer specific
questions or create a system to accomplish the
specified task. Your team writes up a short report and
decides which member of your group makes the
presentation. There is a time limit to accomplish this
task.
The employer then observes your
team as you attempt to accomplish the assigned task.
This activity tests your ability to work in a team.
Can you lead the group in a direction you believe is
important? Equally, can you take direction from your
peers? During this exercise, avoid being domineering
or a wallflower. If you can, display a sense of humor.
Listen carefully to your teammates and build on what
they say, rather than turn discussions to your own
ideas. In these exercises, teams are judged as one,
doing well or poorly together. There are no individual
winners.
Technical Interviews
Technical interviews are based on
Standard, Behavioral and Analytical interviewing
techniques with a more technical emphasis. Primarily
used by employers in engineering, technology, math and
science-related industries, technical interviews
identify your level of skill. Employers ask questions
about where and how you have applied your technical
expertise. Use the STAR system mentioned earlier to
answer these types of behavioral interview questions.
The analytical questions asked in a technical
interview require greater math, computer or technical
knowledge, but they are still designed to see the
process you use to work through a problem.
INTERVIEW
QUESTIONS
to top
Before you begin interviewing,
think about these questions and possible responses and
discuss them with a career counselor. Participate in
mock interviews and be sure you are able to
communicate clear, unrehearsed answers to the
interviewer.
Open-Ended
Questions:
The Two-Minute Drill
"Tell me about yourself" is a frequently
asked question. If the interviewer does not ask this
question, you can effectively lift out portions of a
prepared response to answer other questions. This
question gives the interviewer a chance to sit back
and observe not only what you say, but also how you
say it.
It becomes your two-minute commercial to sell
yourself, to make that first impression count. It
gives the interviewer a strong feeling of who you are.
The interviewer may interrupt and want to know more
about any portion of what you have said. Answer the
question and then continue your presentation.
Guidelines for the two-minute drill include:
(15 - 30 seconds)
1. A brief statement about yourself, family,
hometown, etc.
(30 - 45 seconds)
2. Education, including choice of college, areas of
study, extracurricular activities, etc.
(30 - 45 seconds)
3. Work experience and accomplishments. Or talk
more about classes, projects, leadership experience,
community service commitment, etc.
(15 - 30 seconds)
4. Why are you here? What’s next?
Drill Summary:
1. Personal life
2. Education, including extracurricular activities
3. Experience and accomplishments
4. Why are you here?
If your past experience can be illustrated, prepare
a notebook of samples—a "portfolio"—of
your work to take with you. A portfolio may contain
writing samples, photography, flyers used to advertise
events you were involved in, graphics, copies of
projects, etc.
Standard & Behavioral Questions
Before you begin interviewing,
think about these questions and possible responses and
discuss them with a career counselor. Review the "Types
of Interviews" section on how to answer these
questions. Participate in mock interviews and be sure
you are able to communicate clear, unrehearsed answers
to the interviewers.
Personal
1. Tell me about yourself.
2. What are your hobbies?
3. Why did you choose to interview
with our company?
4. Describe your ideal job.
5. What can you offer us?
16. What do you consider to be your
greatest strengths?
7. Can you name some weaknesses?
8. Define success. Define failure.
9. Have you ever had any failures?
What did you learn from them?
10. Of which three accomplishments
are you most proud?
11. Who are your role models?
12. How does your college education
or work experience relate to this job?
13. What motivates you most in a
job?
14. Have you had difficulty getting
along with a former professor / supervisor / co-worker
and how did you handle it?
15. Have you ever spoken before a
group of people? How large?
16. Why should we hire you rather
than another candidate?
17. What do you know about our
organization (products or services)?
18. Where do you want to be in five
years? Ten years?
19. Do you plan to return to school
for further education?
Education
20. Why did you choose your major?
21. Why did you choose to attend
your college or university?
22. Do you think you received a
good education? In what ways?
23. In which campus activities did
you participate?
24. Which classes in your major did
you like best? Least? Why?
25. Which elective classes did you
like the best? Least? Why?
26. If you were to start over, what
would you change about your education?
27. Do your grades accurately
reflect your ability? Why or why not?
28. Were you financially
responsible for any portion of your college education?
Experience
29. What job-related skills have
you developed?
30. Did you work while going to
school?
31. What did you learn from these
work experiences?
32. What did you enjoy most about
your last employment? Least?
33. Have you ever quit a job? Why?
34. Give an example of a situation
in which you provided a solution to an employer.
35. Give an example of a time in
which you worked under deadline pressure.
36. Have you ever done any
volunteer work? What kind?
37. How do you think a former
supervisor would describe your work?
Career Goals
38. Do you prefer to work under
supervision or on your own?
39. What kind of boss do you
prefer?
40. Would you be successful working
with a team?
41. Do you prefer large or small
organizations?
42. What other types of positions
are you considering?
43. How do you feel about working
in a structured environment?
44. Are you able to work on several
assignments at once?
45. How do you feel about working
overtime?
46. How do you feel about travel?
47. How do you feel about the
possibility of relocating?
48. Are you willing to work
flex-time?
Analytical Questions:
How many blue cars are there in the United States?
(The same question can be asked about morticians,
pianos, and so on.)
How many square yards of pizza are eaten in the
U.S. each year?
Imagine a Rubik’s Cube (a 3*3*3 cube). Now think
of a cube that’s ten-by-ten-by-ten. When you look
at the outer surface, how many different 1*1*1 cubes
do you see?
How many times would the population of China
circle the globe if they held hands?
How many roses are used in the Rose Bowl parade in
a given year?
Estimate the dollar value of all the white paint
used to paint houses in the U.S. last year.
Now that you’ve estimated the dollar value of
white paint, how would you go about getting the
actual value? What data sources, etc., would you
look for?
Estimate the demand for household batteries in the
U.S.
Why is a manhole cover round?
How many liters of water does the civilian
population of the U.S. consume in a given year?
Useful facts:
- There are approximately 250
million people living in the United States.
- The population of China is
approximately one billion people.
- The circumference of the Earth is
approximately 23,000 miles.
Case Study questions
- Moving the Hub
A major airline company is thinking about moving
their hub city in the hopes of saving money. How would
you approach this problem to analyze the
cost-effectiveness of such a move?
- Muddying the Waters
There is a client in the bottled-water industry.
Their market is high in Southern California. Sales are
increasing, but profits are decreasing. What
information do you need to assess what is happening?
- Super Batteries
A client has invented a new type of battery that is
compact and has a much longer life than normal
batteries. It will only be about twice as expensive as
ordinary batteries, but will last ten times as long.
Where would the market be for super batteries? What
are the broader implications for such a product?
- French Fry Vending Machines
A major Idaho potato producer wants to increase
demand for its product and stumbles upon the idea of
vending machines for French Fries. The machines would
have a stock of frozen fries, heat them up and deposit
them in a bag for the customer. Assume this process
yields fries that taste good. What factors would you
take into consideration to determine if this is an
economically feasible venture?
- Green Tires
A client approaches you at a party with an idea for
selling green automobile tires. Without expertise in
the auto or tire industries, how would you estimate
the overall market for tires, the percentage of people
who might be interested in green tires, and the
profitability of such an idea? What factors need to be
considered in determining profitability?
- Hotel Headaches
Your client is the owner and manager of an
exclusive hotel and she seeks to improve profits which
have been declining in recent years. She states that
occupancy during the weekends is usually quite good,
but during the week it is low. It is also known that
visitors to the hotel have recently become less
satisfied with service. The client states further that
she has had to reduce staffing response to lower
occupancy rates. What factors would you want to take
into consideration, and what suggestions would you
offer your client, in order to help improve profits?
- Coffee Vending in San Francisco
A chain of gourmet coffee shops from the
Northwest is considering expansion into the San
Francisco area. They sell coffee, coffee beans,
light snacks, and coffee making equipment. This
chain has been highly successful in the Northwest
and has an extensive distribution system and
well-known name there. What factors should they
consider before opening in the San Francisco Bay
area? What would you expect major cost areas to be
in the new location? How could you reduce those
costs? How should the chain determine the locations
of its Bay Area stores? What other factors are
important for this client to consider?
General Questions to Ask Employers
These questions provide a guideline for questions
to ask employers. Remember that the most effective
questions show that you have done your research and
are sincerely interested in the company. Give some
thought to the questions that you ask. Do NOT ask a
question that you can find the answer to on the
company’s website. Most importantly listen and
respond to what the employer has to say when answering
your question.
1. How often are performance
reviews given?
2. Please describe the duties of
the job for me.
3. What should I expect for the
first six months on the job?
4. What products (or services) are
in the development stage now?
5. Do you have plans for expansion?
6. What are your growth projections
for next year?
7. Have you cut your staff in the
last three years?
8. How do you feel about creativity
and individuality?
9. Is your company environmentally
conscious? In what ways?
10. In what ways is a career with
your company better than one with your competitors?
12. What is the largest single
problem facing your staff (department) now?
13. May I talk with the last person
who held this position?
14. How much authority will I have
over decisions?
15. Do you offer a training
program? How long does it last?
16. Once the probation period is
completed, how much authority will I have over
decisions?
17. Has there been much turnover in
this job area?
18. Do you fill positions from the
outside or promote from within first?
19. What qualities are you looking
for in the candidate who fills this position?
20. What skills are especially
important for someone in this position?
21. What characteristics do the
achievers in this company seem to share?
22. Is there a lot of team/project
work?
23. Will I have the opportunity to
work on special projects?
Questions to ask employers at the Second Interview
- Further clarification on what might be the
initial assignment.
- What are organizational relationships of this
department to the rest of XYZ Corporation?
- How would you describe the work environment
here?
- How would you describe the professional
environment here?
- What types of performance appraisal would I
have? When?
- When are salary reviews scheduled? Based on
what? Performance, experience, cost of living?
- What are the plans for the future of my
potential department and XYZ Corporation?
- Have you had layoffs or cost-reduction programs
recently? What was the problem? Were the employees
assisted in finding new jobs?
- What degree of interdepartmental or interplant
contact is there in this job? What are the
transfer possibilities?
- What background and training do the department
heads and their assistants have?
- What functional area has been the major supplier
of top management people?
- From where were the graduates hired during the
last two years?
- What are your policies concerning benefits
(vacation, pension, insurance, and so on)?
- Is there a tuition refund plan? What is covered
in relocation reimbursement?
- How much travel might there be in this job?
- How long are the typical assignments?
Illegal/inappropriate Interview Questions:
If you feel you have been asked an inappropriate
question during an on-campus interview, report it to a
Career Center staff member immediately. If you feel
you have been asked an inappropriate or illegal
question during an off-campus/on-site interview,
report it to the Career Center Director, jerry
Alexander, at 214-768-2266 or jerry@mail.smu.edu
so we can take appropriate action. The Career Center
frequently coaches employers and students on
interviewing procedure.
There are certain types of
questions that an interviewer should not ask because
of federal regulations. You may wish to formulate how
you would answer, or if you would answer, the
following questions regarding:
• marital status
• family plans or number of
children, ages and child care
• physical data
• criminal records unless
security clearance is necessary
• your religion and race
• rental or ownership of your
home
• spouse’s occupation
• your maiden name
• your age; e.g., "When did
you graduate from high school?"
Be ready for inappropriate questions.
One other
type of question deserves attention. Once in a great
while and fortunately with diminishing regularity, you
may be asked a question that you consider illegal,
unethical, or at least inappropriate. The question may
have to do with marital or family status, race,
gender, or some other taboo topic that has no bearing
upon your capacity to do the job. The question might
be something like, "Will your spouse object to
you traveling alone or with members of the opposite
sex?" Or, "How do you feel about working in
a predominantly white environment?" could be
asked of a job seeker from an underrepresented ethnic
group. An older applicant might hear, "How would
you feel about reporting to a younger
supervisor?"
Marriage, race, and age aren’t supposed to be the
subjects of job interviews. But it can happen. When it
does, it customarily catches the students off-guard.
Stunned, uncertain of how to answer, the student
simply unravels until the thread of the interview has
been lost altogether. For better or worse, so has the
job.
A little forethought might have saved the day.
Anticipate inappropriate questions just as you have
anticipated the predictable ones listed above. How do
you want to answer? Basically, you have three choices.
You can refuse to answer or you can go along with the
employer and respond. Those are two of your choices
and in both cases the results are unpredictable. It
may well be that there was no pernicious intent to the
question and your response, whatever it is, will be
inconsequential. Or the opposite could be true and you
were being deliberately tested by an irascible
employer and your response brought the curtain down on
the job. Or labeled you an easy mark.
The third choice has more merit. Decipher the
question and respond only to its appropriate content,
ignoring the offensive issue. For example, the
question regarding your spouse’s attitude about
work-related travel contains a legitimate, though
unspoken, question. "This job requires travel.
How do you feel about that?" You can respond to
that on your own terms. Forget your spouse. Simply
tell the employer that travel is not a problem for you
(assuming it isn’t, of course). "Working in a
predominantly white environment" can be
translated into a question about the type of
environment within which you prefer to work. No racial
overtones to that. Just describe in non-racial terms
your preferred work environment. Don’t talk about
the age of supervisors. Talk about the relationship
that you’d like between you and your supervisor.
Thinking this through in advance will keep you from
falling apart during the interview. When it’s all
over you can decide if you think the employer made an
honest mistake or acted deviously. And whether or not
you want the job. That has merit.
|